Don't Be Afraid to Break the Layout in Web Design: Go Beyond Borders

Series: Exclusive Web Design—Part 2

Author: Naufan Rusyda Faikar

It's by no means that we should break the rules as some people like to say that rules are made to be broken. Humans are social animals—or should we say political animals—, they tend to want to be part of a group that shares similar values. Where they meet, interact, and connect with people who can fill each other's gaps, thereby helping them achieve certain values in life.

At the same time, people also want to be easily recognized among the crowd, to be able to express themselves, and live their own lives carrying an identity as an individual. As long as it doesn't exclude them from the groups they like to be in, they'll continue to search for something by which can reflects their behavior, style, and personal narratives more accurately.

Today we no longer group people only by demographics, but rather classify them by the values they hold. This has blurred the lines of uniqueness and exclusivity more than ever, leading us to conclude that humans aren't completely unique, in the sense that there isn't any single attribute inherent in them that no one else has. Some attributes will place them in one group, while others will fall into another.

It doesn't matter anymore whether we're unique or not. Rules in certain condition are no longer relevant. What is more important is to show others the values we uphold; values that can relate to a group of people. By introducing to some web designs that might inspire you, this series of articles aims to help you become more accurate in expressing your brand according to its target consumers.

In this article:

First time visiting? Read the first article in this series: Non-Rectangular Images in Web Design: Think Beyond Commonalities.

Hero Section

This is the first part of the page which all visitors see when they visit the website. The very best place to engage them to scroll down or explore the website further. The place where we might want to do some experimentation to be more creative than most websites that still use the "default" hero section design from Bootstrap—which is honestly already really good.

Panasonic creates an illusion where the hero image appears overflow the container, when in fact the solid blue background is made up so that it appear to fill the entire container.
Persimmon, Trip.com, and Qatar Airways demonstrate a fairly popular pattern for travel business websites and property marketplaces where the search feature is an important starting point for their users.
Helen Macpherson Smith Trust show a simple hero design which takes benefit from simple transformation functions.

The five examples above illustrate how simple it is to break the web layout. Almost all the examples in this article use the same technique, yet we'll see how just playing with these few attributes can give a different character out of most websites.

Grid Layout

When discussing web layouts, it's worth revisiting the old days when news media websites like The New York Times struggled to organize information on their homepages. So, they took the only realistic approach which required abusing the table layout. To break up the layout to make it as appealing as physical newspaper, they literaly placed tables inside a table recursively and set the table data cells to different widths. Since we always have colspan and rowspan, so sometimes we prefer them rather than creating separate tables. To accommodate the responsive design needs, news media websites moves to using flexbox so that the columns can wrap automatically when the screen width is less than a certain size.

Cable News Network (CNN) website is among the news websites with the highest information density while maintaining a clear visual hierarchy. If they used grid layouts—like The Atlantic—instead of flexboxes as they're doing now, the density wouldn't be as high.

Depends on the type of business of the client you're working with or a potential business you're thinking of, this layout may be the only one you need after all. But hey, maybe we just want a table layout anyway. Well, even in this modern age, people still use tables to create sophisticated designs.

Try to inspect the Mosaic homepage yourself to see that they really use some table elements to layout their pages.

If we want each item to be evenly sized and distributed, look no further than a grid layout. Or a combination of the two as on the The New York Times website.

The North Face uses a grid layout that's anything but simple which adds another layer of satisfaction. Guess what, they use 12 rows and 13 columns to achieve this depth.
We may also want to add captions like Honda does.

It's not that boring, isn't it? Since we all love photo collages. This kind of layout is also known as a bento grid which we often see in every latest Apple WWDC.

Want something more organic? I heard someone call it a deliberate random layout design—sorry if that sounds weird as it's being translated to English.

It's better to see yourself on the websites of Deux, Hyundai Motor Group, and Beltrame Studio to better understand the term.

If you ask, I have no idea either how on earth they can come up with this idea. Maybe less brutal then? Why not trying a mansory grid?

Shutterstock, Unsplash, and Pinterest are very well known for this type.
Some labels like in the FOREAL homepage? No worries!

Okay, even more simple but still creative:

MSD and Whitehead Institute

What do you think?

Card List

Shifting elements vertically is not only to add visual interest, but sometimes also to add hierarchy so that some elements can appear earlier than others as the user scrolls. Give yourself a chance with this layout as it gets less complicated to look and implement:

Can you recall anything? Exactly, LiDRS, Braze, and Kaplan use a simple transformation for each card to reach this layout design.

What if we only want to adjust either the image or the content of each card? Let's see below.

CBRE, Sumimoto Forestry, and Eidgenössische Technische Hochschule Zürich

A final example that might make the layout looks breaking is by creating the subtle illusion that the cards aren't aligned with each other on the vertical axis, when in fact we're simply using a technique we learned in the previous article.

Can you imagine what's happening on the Bank of America website before bringing up the developer tool?

Call-to-Action

This call-to-action section is another place where we can test our newly ideas.

Tyson Foods, Enel, and British Telecommunications
Sanderson Weatherall and JPMorganChase

Playing with three-dimensional perspective can also add character to the design.

releaf introduces a new perspective on how we can break our layout designs in a 3D setting.

Especially when the element transformation can changes as the user interacts with the cursor.

Carousels, despite their pros and cons in UX studies, still seem to be used frequently and are therefore not immune to the influence of creative experimentation.

Aramco, GSK, and CSS-Tricks
National Geographic, Ferrovial, and OM Digital Solutions
RTRFM and Iberdrola

Forget not to always consider common design pattern so that our potential customers won't regret coming to our website. Breaking something doesn't mean breaking everything, right?

Paragraph Breakout

The float attribute has been around for over two decades; it's been there since the first version of Safari, as well as the first versions of both Chrome and Firefox on the desktop. Its adoption is getting really high—according to Chrome Platform Status—so that it's easy to find float attribute on the code more than flex-* and grid-* which are the new CSS layouts released around 2013 and 2017 respectively—as shown in the browser compatibility table on MDN website. Yet when it comes to articles, it's not that easy to spot them on today's leading blogging platforms such as Medium, DEV, and Substack.

The easiest example we can find is Wikipedia as they have been consistently doing the layout since 2004.
Another good example is Nestle website when accessed through desktop, in contrast to Unilever's where it becomes clearly visible on a tablet screen, but not on either of them on a mobile screen size which still makes sense.

Nowadays, the majority of website layouts are far too simple, especially since the emergence of flexbox and grid layouts in major browsers. Or maybe since the rise of the mobile-first design philosophy which seems to be misunderstood by some people. Anyway, I still have some faiths that this particular layout is and will still be used by large established companies, but just not by media companies like The New Yorker, The Atlantic, and The Economist.

I can relate though when many people complain about the unpredictable behavior caused by the float attribute. Ultimately, the feature makes a layout more attractive, as well as increasing the density of information. Use when appropriate, but with caution.

Moreover, we can use the shape-outside attribute to add interesting non-rectangular shapes around adjacent inline content.

Article Breakout

A less brutal approach might be what we call a layout breakout—just google it ourselves&mdash, yet it doesn't seem to be straightforward to implement as a beginner web developer. However, it's rather easy once we get to see a code example. We may want to use a tool for that instead of coding it ourselves from scratch—it won't be considered a taboo :)

It's not so easy to find examples, but hey we can see them in some articles on Medium.

Drop Cap

Remember when the last time we saw drop caps in either physical books or the digital realms?

The New Yorker

Ah, yes, the initial-letter hasn't gained widespread support, but still it's possible to replicate what The New Yorker has been doing.